Eliza, Author at PreProduct

Backorder vs Out of Stock: What’s the Difference (and When to Use Each)

Understanding backorder vs out of stock is essential for any ecommerce merchant facing inventory gaps. Stockouts cost retailers $1.2 trillion globally every year in direct lost sales alone. When customers land on a product page and can’t buy what they want, the consequences ripple through your revenue, customer loyalty and brand perception.

But there’s more than one way to handle out of stock ecommerce situations. You can mark products as “out of stock” and block purchases entirely. You can accept backorders and let customers buy now for later delivery. Or you can take a third approach that some merchants overlook: pre-orders.

Understanding the difference between backorder vs out of stock (and knowing when each makes sense) can mean the difference between capturing revenue and losing customers to competitors. By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly which approach fits your situation.

What Does Backorder Mean? Understanding Backorder Meaning

So what does backorder mean exactly? A backorder happens when a product is temporarily unavailable but customers can still purchase it. The backorder meaning is simple: the item isn’t in your warehouse right now, but you’ve confirmed that more inventory is coming. Customers place their order, you take payment (or vault their card), and you ship once stock arrives.

Think of backorders as a promise: “We don’t have it today, but we will soon, and we’re holding your spot.”

The key characteristics of a backorder:

Customers can still purchase the product despite zero inventory
Restocking is confirmed with a known or estimated timeline
Payment is typically collected upfront or at time of shipment
Fulfillment is delayed until inventory is replenished

Backorders usually work best for short restocking windows. On average, it takes 14-21 days to fulfill a backorder, though this varies by product and supply chain. The shorter the window, the more willing customers are to wait.

From an operational perspective, backorders let you continue taking orders rather than turning customers away. But they also create fulfillment complexity. You need systems to track incoming inventory, manage customer expectations, and process payments at the right time.

What Does Out of Stock Mean?

When a product is marked “out of stock,” customers cannot purchase it at all. The buy button is disabled, replaced with a “Sold Out” badge, or the product may be hidden from your store entirely.

An out-of-stock status signals uncertainty. Unlike backorders, there’s no guarantee the product will return, and no commitment to a timeline. Customers have to wait and hope, or look elsewhere.

The key characteristics of out of stock:

Customers cannot purchase the product
Restocking timeline is unknown or uncertain
No payment is collected
The product may or may not return

Out of stock is the default setting for most ecommerce platforms when inventory hits zero. It’s the safest approach from a fulfillment standpoint because you’re not making promises you can’t keep. But it’s also the most expensive from a revenue standpoint.

When customers encounter out-of-stock products, 69% abandon their purchase entirely and shop elsewhere. And 43% will go directly to a competitor. Every “Sold Out” badge is a potential lost customer.

Key Differences Between Backorder and Out of Stock

The fundamental difference comes down to purchase availability and customer commitment. Here’s how they compare:

Factor	Backorder	Out of Stock
Can customers purchase?	Yes, with delayed fulfillment	No, purchase blocked
Restocking timeline	Confirmed or estimated	Unknown or indefinite
Payment timing	Upfront or deferred	None
Customer expectation	“My order is coming soon”	“Maybe it will come back”
Revenue impact	Preserved (delayed)	Lost
Operational complexity	Higher	Lower

From a customer psychology perspective, the difference is significant. A backorder customer has made a commitment. They’ve decided to buy, entered their payment details and are waiting for delivery. An out-of-stock customer hasn’t committed to anything. They’re still in consideration mode and can easily be distracted by a competitor.

This psychological difference matters for your business. Customers who have already committed are less likely to cancel or shop around. But backorder customers also have higher expectations. They expect clear communication, accurate timelines and a smooth delivery experience.

When to Use Backorders

Backorders work best in specific scenarios where you have confidence in your restocking timeline and customers are willing to wait.

Fast-moving bestsellers

When a popular product sells out faster than expected, backorders let you continue capturing demand. If you have a reliable supplier and predictable restocking timeline, accepting backorders keeps sales flowing while you wait for the next shipment.

Core catalog items

For products that are a permanent part of your catalog, backorders make sense during temporary stockouts. These are items you’ll definitely restock, and customers know they’re getting a product that’s proven and available.

Short restocking windows

Backorders work best when the wait time is measured in days or weeks, not months. The sweet spot is typically 2-6 weeks. Beyond that, customer patience wears thin and cancellation risk increases.

Reliable supplier relationships

Only offer backorders when you’re confident in your restocking timeline. If your supply chain is unpredictable, making promises you can’t keep will damage customer trust more than simply saying “out of stock.”

When NOT to use backorders:

Seasonal items unlikely to restock this season
Products with uncertain supply chains
Wait times beyond 8-12 weeks
Items being discontinued or phased out

The risk with backorders is overpromising. If you tell customers their order will ship in two weeks and it takes six, you’ve created a support headache and potentially lost their trust for future purchases.

When to Mark Products Out of Stock

Sometimes the safest approach is to be upfront: this product isn’t available, and you can’t make promises about when it will return.

Discontinued products

If you’re not bringing a product back, don’t pretend otherwise. Mark it out of stock (or redirect to an alternative) and move on. Accepting backorders for discontinued items is a recipe for refunds and complaints.

Uncertain restocking timelines

When you genuinely don’t know when inventory will arrive, it’s better to be honest. Telling customers “out of stock” is more trustworthy than making up a timeline you can’t guarantee.

Supply chain disruptions

Major supply chain issues can make restocking timelines impossible to predict. During periods of uncertainty, marking products out of stock protects both customer expectations and your operations team.

Quality or compliance issues

If a product is unavailable due to quality concerns or regulatory issues, you need to resolve those before selling again. Out of stock is the appropriate status while you work through the problem.

The downside of out of stock is lost revenue. But the upside is operational simplicity and honest customer communication. Sometimes it’s better to lose a sale today than damage trust with a broken promise.

For Shopify merchants dealing with stockouts, we’ve written a comprehensive guide on what to do when products are out of stock on Shopify, covering strategies from hiding products to setting up notifications. Understanding Shopify backorder functionality is crucial for maintaining sales during inventory gaps.

The Third Option: Preorder vs Backorder

Here’s where most backorder vs out of stock discussions fall short. They treat these as the only two options when there’s a third approach that often works better for ecommerce: pre-orders.

Understanding preorder vs backorder differences is crucial for choosing the right strategy. Pre-orders are different from backorders in a few important ways:

Proactive vs reactive: Pre-orders are typically used for new products or planned restocks, while backorders are reactive responses to unexpected stockouts
Longer acceptable timeframes: Customers willingly wait months for pre-orders but lose patience after a few weeks with backorders
Different psychology: Pre-order customers are excited early adopters; backorder customers are frustrated buyers whose item wasn’t available

The data backs this up. According to our analysis of over one million pre-orders generating $85M+ in revenue, the most common pre-order shipping timeframe is 121-150 days. That’s 4-5 months. Customers don’t just tolerate these wait times, they expect them.

The average pre-order cancellation rate? Just 5.4%. Despite wait times that would be unacceptable for a backorder, pre-order customers stay committed because they’ve made a conscious choice to wait for something they want.

Another insight: 90.4% of pre-orders carry no discount. Customers aren’t waiting because they got a deal. They’re waiting because they want early access to the product. This is fundamentally different psychology than a backorder, where customers often feel they’re being inconvenienced.

When pre-orders work better than backorders:

New product launches (build anticipation before inventory arrives)
Restocks with longer lead times (4+ weeks)
Made-to-order or custom products
Limited edition drops (create scarcity and urgency)
Seasonal products returning next season

Pre-orders also give you payment flexibility that backorders typically don’t. With charge-later pre-orders, you can vault a customer’s card at checkout and charge when you’re ready to ship. This reduces refund risk for longer timelines while still capturing customer commitment.

For a deeper comparison, see our guide on pre-orders vs backorders vs waitlists.

How to Choose Between Backorder vs Out of Stock

With three options available, how do you decide which approach fits your situation? Here’s a decision framework based on the most common backorder vs out of stock scenarios:

Scenario	Best Approach	Why
Known restock date (2-4 weeks)	Backorder	Short wait, high confidence, keep sales flowing
Known restock date (4-12 weeks)	Pre-order with charge-later	Longer wait needs proper expectation-setting
Unknown restock timeline	Back-in-stock notification	Don’t make promises you can’t keep
New product launch	Pre-order	Build anticipation, capture early demand
Seasonal product (returning later)	Pre-order or notification	Depends on how far out the restock is
Product being discontinued	Out of stock + redirect	Don’t accept orders you can’t fulfill
Made-to-order items	Pre-order with deposit	Collect commitment before production
High-ticket items	Pre-order with deposit	Reduce risk for both parties

The key questions to ask:

How confident are you in the restock timeline? High confidence = backorder or pre-order. Low confidence = out of stock or notification.
How long will customers wait? Under 4 weeks = backorder probably works. Over 4 weeks = consider pre-orders with proper messaging.
Is this a new launch or a restock? New launches benefit from pre-order anticipation. Restocks can go either way.
What’s the price point? Higher-ticket items may warrant deposit-based pre-orders to secure customer commitment.
How will this affect your operations? Backorders and pre-orders both require systems to track orders, manage fulfillment holds and communicate with customers.

Best Practices for Shopify Backorder and Out of Stock Management

Regardless of which approach you choose, clear communication is essential. Customers can handle waiting. What they can’t handle is uncertainty. Here are best practices for managing backorder vs out of stock situations in your store.

Set expectations on the product page

Don’t bury the shipping timeline in fine print. If an item is on backorder or pre-order, make the expected delivery date prominent. “Ships in 2-3 weeks” or “Expected ship date: April 15” gives customers the information they need to decide.

Use dedicated buttons and messaging

A generic “Add to Cart” button doesn’t tell customers they’re committing to a delayed order. Use clear labels like “Pre-order Now” or “Backorder” to signal that this isn’t a standard purchase.

Send automated updates

Keep customers informed throughout the wait. A simple “Your order is still on track to ship next week” email can prevent support tickets and build trust. If timelines change, communicate proactively.

Consider payment timing carefully

For short backorders, charging upfront is usually fine. For longer waits (especially 30+ days), consider charge-later options where you vault the customer’s card and charge closer to shipment. This reduces refund requests and expired card issues.

Our data shows that 43.8% of pre-order listings use charge-later, which suggests merchants are finding value in delaying payment for longer lead times.

Forecast demand to prevent stockouts

The best backorder strategy is avoiding backorders in the first place. Use inventory forecasting tools and pre-order inventory management to predict demand and set reorder points that give you buffer before running out.

Don’t overcommit

If you’re not sure how much inventory you’ll receive, consider capping backorders or pre-orders to avoid overselling. It’s better to turn away some orders than to cancel orders after customers have committed.

Putting It All Together: Backorder vs Out of Stock

The backorder vs out of stock decision isn’t just about definitions. It’s about choosing the right tool for your specific out of stock ecommerce situation.

Backorders keep sales flowing during short, predictable stockouts. They work best when you have confidence in your restocking timeline and customers are willing to wait a few weeks.

Out of stock is the honest approach when you can’t make promises. It protects customer trust and operational simplicity, even though it means lost sales in the short term.

Pre-orders offer a third path that many merchants overlook. When comparing preorder vs backorder options, pre-orders handle longer timelines, build anticipation for new products and give you payment flexibility that backorders don’t. For most ecommerce scenarios beyond simple restocks, Shopify pre-orders are worth considering.

The common thread across all three approaches? Communication. Customers can handle delays when they know what to expect. What they can’t handle is uncertainty, broken promises or radio silence.

If you’re running a Shopify store and want to explore pre-orders as an alternative to Shopify backorder management, our guide on how to do pre-orders on Shopify covers the full setup process. And for managing inventory across pre-orders and regular stock, see our guide on managing pre-order inventory in Shopify.

Whatever approach you choose, the goal is the same: capture demand, keep customers informed and deliver on your promises.

Pre-sell With PreProduct

7 day free trial with all plans

Contents

What Does Backorder Mean? Understanding Backorder Meaning
What Does Out of Stock Mean?
Key Differences Between Backorder and Out of Stock
When to Use Backorders
When to Mark Products Out of Stock
The Third Option: Preorder vs Backorder
How to Choose Between Backorder vs Out of Stock
Best Practices for Shopify Backorder and Out of Stock Management
Putting It All Together: Backorder vs Out of Stock

Out of Stock on Shopify: What to Do (and How to Keep Selling)

Prefer a video? Click here to watch Oli explain your options when products sell out of stock.

Your best-selling product hits zero inventory. Shopify slaps a “Sold Out” badge on it and blocks purchases. Customers land on the page, see the greyed-out button and leave. Some buy from a competitor instead.

This is what happens by default when products go out of stock on Shopify. And it costs more than you think. According to industry research, 69% of online shoppers will abandon a purchase entirely and shop with a competitor when they encounter an out-of-stock item. For first-time visitors, the damage is even worse: 42% are unlikely to return after hitting a stockout.

But a product going out of stock doesn’t have to mean lost revenue. Stockouts are increasingly common across popular product categories, and there are several ways to handle them, from quick settings changes to revenue-preserving strategies like pre-orders and back-in-stock notifications. The right approach depends on your situation: whether the product is coming back, how long restocking takes and how you want to manage customer expectations.

This guide walks through every option available to Shopify merchants.

Why Does My Shopify Store Say “Sold Out”?

Before jumping into strategies, it’s worth understanding why a product shows as sold out on Shopify in the first place. Sometimes it’s expected (inventory genuinely hit zero). Other times it’s a settings issue that’s costing you sales unnecessarily.

Here are the most common causes:

Inventory genuinely reached zero. This is the straightforward one. Shopify tracks inventory quantities, and when a product or variant drops to zero, the buy button is replaced with “Sold Out.” This is default Shopify behaviour and it’s working as intended.

Inventory tracking is misconfigured. If “Track quantity” is turned on but no inventory count was entered, the product defaults to zero. This catches merchants who add new products without setting initial stock levels. Check the Inventory section of your product in Shopify admin and make sure quantities are correct.

Multi-location inventory confusion. If you use multiple inventory locations in Shopify (warehouse, retail store, 3PL), a product can show as sold out if the location assigned to your online store has zero stock, even if other locations have plenty. Verify that the right location is stocked and assigned.

Variant-level stock issues. A product with multiple variants (sizes, colours) can appear partially or fully sold out if individual variants hit zero. One variant at zero stock won’t necessarily make the whole product unavailable, but it can confuse customers if the default-selected variant is the one that’s out of stock.

Sync problems with third-party apps. If you use a 3PL, ERP or multi-channel selling tool, inventory syncs can lag or fail. This is a common frustration in Shopify community forums, with merchants posting about products showing “Sold Out” despite having stock on hand. If this is happening, check your integration settings and sync logs.

Once you’ve ruled out (or fixed) technical issues, the next question is: what do you do when a product is legitimately out of stock?

The Shopify “Continue Selling When Out of Stock” Setting

Shopify has a built-in setting that lets you keep accepting orders even when inventory drops to zero. It’s a checkbox labelled “Continue selling when out of stock” in the Inventory section of any product or variant.

How to enable it:

Go to Products in your Shopify admin
Click into the product you want to update
Scroll to the Inventory section (or click into a specific variant)
Check “Continue selling when out of stock”
Save

Once enabled, the buy button stays active regardless of inventory count. Customers can purchase even when stock is at zero or negative.

When this makes sense:

You have confirmed restock coming soon (within days)
You’re running a made-to-order or build-to-order model
You’re pairing it with a pre-order app that manages expectations
You have a reliable supply chain with short lead times

When it gets risky:

This setting is not a “set and forget” solution. The biggest risk is customer expectations. If someone buys a product expecting normal shipping and then discovers it won’t ship for weeks, you’ll get support tickets, refund requests and potentially chargebacks.

Without clear messaging on the product page, at checkout and in order confirmation emails, enabling this checkbox alone can create more problems than it solves. If you’re going to use it, pair it with one of the strategies below.

Five Strategies for Out-of-Stock Products on Shopify

There’s no single right answer for every stockout. The best approach depends on whether the product is coming back, how long restocking takes and what kind of customer experience you want to deliver. Here are five options.

1. Take pre-orders

Pre-orders let you keep accepting orders for out-of-stock products with full transparency about when they’ll ship. Instead of hiding the product or blocking purchases, you give customers the option to buy now and receive the product later.

This is the most revenue-positive approach for products that are definitely coming back.

A pre-order app like PreProduct replaces your standard “Add to Cart” button with a pre-order button when a product is out of stock. It manages customer expectations through customisable front-end messaging, email updates and customer portals.

Payment flexibility matters here. Not every pre-order needs to charge upfront. Depending on your situation, you can:

Charge upfront: Collect full payment now. Best for short lead times where you know the product will ship soon.
Charge later: Vault the customer’s card and charge when stock arrives. Good for longer lead times where you want to reduce refund risk.
Take a deposit: Collect a percentage upfront and charge the balance later. Useful for higher-ticket items where you want commitment without asking for the full amount.

Pre-orders also give you valuable demand data. If 200 people pre-order a product, you have a much clearer picture of how much inventory to order than if you just showed a “Sold Out” badge and guessed.

Best for: Products being restocked, new launches, seasonal items coming back, made-to-order products.

2. Set up Shopify out of stock notifications

If you’re not sure when a product will be available again (or don’t want to commit to a timeline), back-in-stock notifications let customers sign up to be alerted when the product returns.

This typically involves adding a “Notify Me” or “Email Me When Available” button to sold-out product pages. When the product is restocked, subscribed customers receive an email or SMS notification.

The main advantage is low risk. You’re not taking payment or making a fulfilment promise. You’re just collecting intent signals.

The downside is that you’re not capturing revenue. The customer leaves your store without buying, and there’s no guarantee they’ll come back when notified. Open rates on back-in-stock emails can be strong, but conversion rates vary widely depending on how long the customer has been waiting and whether they found an alternative.

Best for: Uncertain restock timelines, products that may or may not return, lower-ticket items where pre-orders feel excessive.

3. Hide out-of-stock products or push them down

Rather than showing customers products they can’t buy, some merchants prefer to hide out of stock products on Shopify or de-prioritise sold-out items. There are a few ways to do this.

Smart collections filtering. You can set up a smart collection with the condition “Inventory stock is greater than 0” to automatically exclude out-of-stock products from collection pages. This keeps your browsing experience clean.

Shopify’s “unlisted” status. Introduced in late 2025, you can set a product status to “Unlisted.” The product won’t appear in your storefront search or collection pages, but the URL remains accessible. This is useful for SEO because search engines can still crawl and index the page.

Push-down apps. Several Shopify apps (like Nada or StockIQ) automatically move sold-out products to the bottom of collection pages rather than hiding them entirely. This keeps the page live for SEO while improving the browsing experience.

A word of caution on hiding products: If you unpublish or delete a product page, you risk losing any SEO value that page has built up, including backlinks, indexed pages and ranking signals. More on this in the SEO section below.

Best for: Large catalogues where browsing experience matters, seasonal products that won’t return for months, discontinued items.

4. Recommend alternative products

When a product is out of stock, don’t let the customer hit a dead end. Use the sold-out product page as a jumping-off point to suggest similar items they might want instead.

You can do this with:

Shopify’s built-in product recommendations (based on purchase patterns and product descriptions)
Manual “You might also like” sections using related products
App-powered recommendations that use browsing behaviour and purchase history

This is especially effective for stores with large catalogues where multiple products can fill a similar need. A customer looking for a specific colour of t-shirt might happily buy a different colour if it’s presented well.

Best for: Large catalogues with substitutable products, discontinued items with successors, fashion and lifestyle brands with range depth.

5. Show estimated restock dates

Sometimes the simplest approach is the most effective: tell customers when the product will be back.

Adding an estimated restock date to the product page (“Expected back in stock: March 15”) sets clear expectations. Customers can decide whether to wait, sign up for a notification or look elsewhere.

This works particularly well when paired with pre-orders. Instead of just showing a date, you can let customers place a pre-order with the restock date displayed prominently. That way they know exactly when to expect delivery.

Best for: Products with predictable restock timelines, brands that prioritise transparency, items with consistent demand.

Which Out-of-Stock Strategy Should You Use?

The right approach depends on a few factors. Here’s a quick decision framework:

Situation	Best Strategy	Why
Product is being restocked (known timeline)	Pre-orders	Capture revenue now; ship when ready
Product might come back (unclear timeline)	Back-in-stock notifications	Collect interest without committing
Product is discontinued	Hide + redirect (301)	Preserve SEO; guide customers to alternatives
Product is seasonal (returning later)	Hide + notifications	Clean up browsing experience; re-engage later
Large catalogue with many substitutes	Recommend alternatives	Keep the customer shopping on your store
High-demand product with waitlist potential	Pre-orders + restock date	Maximise revenue capture; build anticipation

In practice, many stores combine strategies. For example, you might take pre-orders for your best-sellers while hiding lower-priority out-of-stock products and showing alternatives for discontinued items.

How Out-of-Stock Pages Affect Your Shopify SEO

How you handle out-of-stock products has real SEO implications. Get it wrong and you can lose rankings, traffic and link equity that took months to build.

Here’s what to keep in mind:

Don’t delete product pages that have backlinks or organic traffic. If a product page has earned backlinks from other websites, or ranks for any keywords in Google, deleting it creates a 404 error and throws away that SEO value. Even if the product is gone, the page still carries weight.

Use 301 redirects for permanently discontinued products. If a product is never coming back, set up a 301 redirect to the most relevant alternative: a similar product, the parent collection page, or a newer version. Avoid redirecting everything to your homepage. Google treats homepage redirects as “soft 404s,” which means you still lose the SEO value.

Keep temporarily out-of-stock pages live. If the product is coming back, leave the page active. You can update the product description to reflect availability (adding a pre-order option, a notification sign-up, or an expected restock date) while keeping the URL indexed and ranking.

Use availability schema markup. Shopify themes generally include product structured data, but make sure the availability status is accurate. Setting it to “PreOrder” or “BackOrder” (rather than just “OutOfStock”) tells Google the product is still purchasable, which can help maintain visibility in search results and Google Shopping.

Consider Shopify’s “unlisted” status for seasonal products. If you want to remove a product from your storefront without affecting its SEO, “unlisted” keeps the URL live and crawlable while hiding it from your store’s search and collection pages.

Automate with Shopify Flow. If you’re managing a large catalogue, manually updating product statuses is tedious. Shopify Flow can automate actions like tagging products when inventory hits zero, hiding them from collections and republishing when stock is added back.

Preventing Out of Stock on Shopify in the First Place

The best out-of-stock strategy is not needing one. While stockouts happen to every Shopify store eventually, there are ways to reduce their frequency.

Track inventory levels and set low-stock alerts. Shopify lets you set up notifications when inventory drops below a threshold. Use these to trigger reorder processes before stock actually runs out.

Use pre-orders to gauge demand before committing to inventory. One of the biggest advantages of pre-orders is demand validation. If you’re launching a new product or restocking, taking pre-orders first tells you exactly how much inventory to order. This reduces the risk of overstocking (and the discounting that follows) while ensuring you don’t run out.

Diversify suppliers for best-sellers. If a single supplier has issues, your top products go out of stock. Having backup suppliers or manufacturers reduces this risk, even if the cost per unit is slightly higher.

Build safety stock buffers for high-velocity SKUs. Safety stock is extra inventory held as a buffer against unexpected demand spikes or supply delays. For your highest-selling products, maintaining even a small buffer can prevent the revenue loss that comes with a stockout.

Forecast demand using historical data. Look at your sales trends, seasonality and marketing calendar to anticipate demand. If you’re running a promotion that drives a traffic spike, make sure your top products have enough inventory to handle it.

Wrapping Up

Products going out of stock on Shopify is inevitable. What matters is how you handle it.

If the product is coming back, pre-orders are the most effective way to keep capturing revenue while being transparent with customers. If you’re not sure about restocking, back-in-stock notifications collect interest without commitment. For discontinued products, clean redirects and product recommendations keep your SEO intact and your customers engaged.

The key is matching the strategy to the situation rather than defaulting to a “Sold Out” badge and hoping customers come back later. In most cases, they won’t.

Whatever approach you choose, clear communication is what separates a good out of stock experience on Shopify from a frustrating one. Tell customers what’s happening, when to expect the product, and what their options are. That transparency builds trust, even when the product isn’t available yet.

Ready to turn stockouts into pre-orders? Start taking pre-orders on Shopify with PreProduct and keep selling even when inventory hits zero.

Pre-sell With PreProduct

7 day free trial with all plans

Contents

Why Does My Shopify Store Say “Sold Out”?
The Shopify “Continue Selling When Out of Stock” Setting
Five Strategies for Out-of-Stock Products on Shopify
Which Out-of-Stock Strategy Should You Use?
How Out-of-Stock Pages Affect Your Shopify SEO
Preventing Out of Stock on Shopify in the First Place
Wrapping Up

How Do Pre-Orders Work? Everything You Need to Know

Pre-orders let customers buy products before they’re available to ship. It’s a simple concept, but the mechanics behind how pre-orders work can vary depending on the payment model, the platform and the type of product being sold.

At PreProduct, we’ve processed over $85 million in pre-order sales across more than 1 million orders. That dataset gives us a clear picture of how pre-orders actually work in ecommerce, who uses them, what payment models perform best and how long customers are willing to wait.

This guide breaks down how pre-orders work from both sides of the transaction. Whether you’re a customer wondering what happens when you pre-order something or a merchant exploring whether pre-orders make sense for your store, this covers everything you need to know.

What Does Pre-Order Mean?

So what does pre-order mean exactly? The pre-order meaning is straightforward: it’s an order placed for a product that isn’t yet available or in stock. The customer commits to buying the item, and the merchant commits to delivering it once it’s ready.

Pre-orders are common across ecommerce, not just gaming and entertainment. According to data from 1 million+ pre-orders processed through PreProduct, the top industries using pre-orders are apparel (16.7%) and beauty and fitness (13.9%). Fashion brands, tech companies, beauty labels and food producers all use pre-orders to take orders before stock arrives.

It’s worth noting the differences between related concepts. A pre-order is for a product that’s coming soon or being restocked. A backorder is for a product that’s already listed but temporarily out of stock. A waitlist collects interest without any purchase commitment. Each serves a different purpose, and you can read our full breakdown of pre-orders vs backorders vs waitlists for more detail.

How Pre-Orders Work Step by Step

Understanding how pre-ordering works is easier when you see the full process laid out. The pre-order flow follows a straightforward path, whether you’re selling on Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce or any other platform.

1. The merchant lists a product for pre-order.
This could be an upcoming launch, a restock of a sold-out item or a made-to-order product. A pre-order app or tool replaces the standard “add to cart” button with a pre-order button and displays companion wording like estimated shipping dates or payment terms.

2. The customer places a pre-order.
They browse the product page, see the pre-order terms and click to buy. The checkout experience is similar to a regular purchase, with any pre-order-specific details (like estimated shipping dates) shown before they confirm.

3. Payment is collected.
This is where pre-orders diverge from regular orders. Depending on the merchant’s setup, the customer might be charged immediately, later when the product ships, or asked to pay a deposit upfront. We’ll cover the payment models in detail below.

4. The merchant communicates updates.
Good pre-order experiences depend on communication. Merchants keep customers informed about production progress, shipping timelines and any changes to the expected delivery date.

5. Stock arrives and the merchant fulfils orders.
Once stock is in hand, the merchant processes the pre-orders. If payment was deferred, charges are triggered at this stage. Fulfilment holds are released, and orders flow through to shipping.

6. The customer receives their product.
The pre-order is complete. From the customer’s perspective, the main difference between a pre-order vs a regular order is the wait, which can range from a few days to several months.

That’s how pre-ordering works at a high level. However, the payment step is where things get interesting.

How Do You Pay for a Pre-Order?

One of the most common questions about how pre-orders work is whether you pay for pre-orders immediately. The answer depends on the payment model the merchant uses.

Based on data from over 1 million pre-orders, here are the four main payment models and how often merchants use them:

Payment Model	% of Listings	When You’re Charged
Charge-later	43.8%	When product is ready to ship
Capture-only / payment link	28.7%	When merchant sends payment link
Charge-upfront	14.9%	Immediately at checkout
Deposit-upfront	12.6%	Partial now, balance later

Charge-later (43.8% of listings)
The most popular model on PreProduct (Shopify and BigCommerce). The customer’s card is vaulted (saved securely) at checkout, but they’re not charged until the product is ready to ship. This gives customers confidence that they won’t pay for something that isn’t ready, while still letting the merchant secure the order.

Capture-only / payment link (28.7% of listings)
The merchant collects the customer’s payment intent and sends a payment link when the product is ready. This works well for merchants who want to avoid holding customer payment details for extended periods.

Charge-upfront (14.9% of listings)
The customer pays the full price at checkout, just like a regular order. The merchant gets immediate cash flow, but takes on more responsibility to deliver on time. This model works best when the product is close to shipping.

Deposit-upfront (12.6% of listings)
The customer pays a partial amount (the deposit) at checkout, with the balance collected later. This strikes a balance between securing commitment and reducing risk for the customer. It’s popular for higher-ticket items where paying the full amount months in advance feels like a bigger ask. Learn more about how deposit pre-orders on Shopify work.

Each model suits different situations. Short lead times pair well with charge-upfront. Longer waits tend to favour charge-later or deposits. For a deeper comparison, see our pre-order payment models guide.

Why Do Merchants Offer Pre-Orders?

Merchants run pre-orders for practical reasons, not just to build hype. Here’s what drives them:

Take orders and revenue sooner. You don’t have to wait until stock is sitting in your warehouse to start selling. Pre-orders let you capture demand as soon as a product is announced or listed, whether it’s a brand new launch or a restock of something that sold out.

Validate demand before committing to inventory. Pre-orders give you real purchase data for demand forecasting, not just interest or email signups. If 500 people place pre-orders for a new product, you know exactly how much to manufacture. This reduces the risk of overproducing and having to discount or write off unsold stock.

Improve cash flow. With charge-upfront or deposit models, revenue starts coming in before you’ve paid for manufacturing or shipping. That cash can fund the production run itself, which is why pre-orders are especially popular with smaller brands and independent makers.

Avoid missed sales on out-of-stock products. When a popular product sells out, most stores put up a “sold out” message and lose the sale. Pre-orders keep the revenue flowing by letting customers secure their order and wait for the restock.

Build anticipation for product launches. A well-run pre-order campaign creates momentum. Customers who pre-order are invested in the product and often share it with others. Brands like Daylight Computer have turned pre-orders into a VIP experience, offering a “Founders Edition” insider club that transforms the wait into part of the appeal.

Use data to plan production. Pre-order numbers give you concrete demand forecasting data. Instead of guessing how many units to produce, you can base manufacturing decisions on actual orders. This is especially valuable for brands producing in small batches or working with seasonal suppliers.

One insight from our dataset that surprises people: 90.4% of pre-orders are not discounted. Customers pre-order for access, not savings. They want to be first in line, not to get a deal. That’s a meaningful signal for merchants who assume they need to offer a discount to make pre-orders work.

Cancellation rates are low too. The average across our dataset is just 5.4%, which suggests customers who pre-order are genuinely committed. Understanding how pre-orders work from the merchant side makes it clear why so many brands build them into their launch strategy.

When Do Pre-Orders Make Sense (and When They Don’t)

Pre-orders aren’t the right fit for every situation. Here’s a practical framework for deciding.

Pre-orders work well for:

New product launches. You’re confident the product is coming. Pre-orders let you build demand and take revenue before it ships.
Restocks of popular items. A product sold out and you know it’s coming back. Pre-orders capture customers who don’t want to miss it again.
Limited editions and seasonal collections. Scarcity and time-sensitivity make pre-orders a natural fit.
Higher-value items. Products priced at $250 or more make up 26.8% of pre-order listings in our dataset. Customers are willing to commit early for items they’ve been eyeing.
Made-to-order products. Brands like Frahm Jackets use pre-orders as a core part of their business model. As they put it: “Each design is made once a year. We deliberately don’t make enough to meet demand, so we don’t overbuy.”

Pre-orders are less ideal for:

Very short timelines (under seven days). If the product is shipping that soon, a regular order is simpler for everyone.
Products with uncertain specs or timelines. If you don’t know what the final product looks like or when it’ll be ready, you’re setting up for frustrated customers.
Merchants without communication systems in place. Pre-orders require keeping customers informed. If you can’t send updates about shipping timelines or production status, the experience falls apart.

The simplest test: if you know you’re going to sell the product and just need time for stock to arrive, pre-orders are a good fit.

How Long Do Pre-Orders Take to Ship?

How long do pre-orders take? Shipping timelines vary widely depending on the product, the manufacturer and the supply chain involved.

From our dataset, the most common pre-order shipping timeframe is 121-150 days, accounting for 28.1% of all pre-order listings. However, 20.6% of pre-orders ship within 30 days, so there’s a wide range.

Shipping Timeframe	% of Listings
0-30 days	20.6%
31-60 days	13.2%
61-90 days	11.9%
91-120 days	15.4%
121-150 days	28.1%
150+ days	10.8%

The specific duration matters less than transparency. Customers are willing to wait months for a product they want, as long as they know what to expect. The merchants who run successful pre-order campaigns communicate estimated shipping dates clearly on the product page and send updates if anything changes.

If you’re managing inventory around pre-orders, our guide on how to manage pre-order inventory in Shopify covers the operational side in detail.

Pre-Order FAQs

Do you get charged right away for a pre-order?
It depends on the merchant. 43.8% of pre-order listings on PreProduct use a charge-later model, meaning you won’t be charged until the product is ready to ship. Others charge upfront or take a deposit. The payment terms should be clearly stated on the product page before you checkout.

Can pre-orders sell out?
Yes. Merchants can set limits on how many pre-orders they accept. This is common for limited-edition releases or products with capped production runs. Once the limit is reached, the pre-order option is removed.

Can you cancel a pre-order?
In most cases, yes. The average cancellation rate across our dataset is 5.4%, which means the vast majority of customers keep their pre-orders. Cancellation policies vary by merchant, so check the store’s pre-order policy before placing your order.

Do pre-orders cost more than regular orders?
Typically no. 90.4% of pre-orders in our dataset are sold at the regular price with no discount applied. Some merchants offer an early-bird discount or deposit incentive, but this is the exception rather than the rule.

What’s the difference between a pre-order and a backorder?
A pre-order is placed before a product launches or while it’s being restocked. A backorder is placed for a product that was in stock, sold out and is being replenished. The customer experience is similar, but the context is different. Read our full pre-orders vs backorders vs waitlists comparison for more detail.

What’s the difference between a pre-order vs a regular order?
The main difference is timing. A regular order ships from available stock straight away. A pre-order is placed before the product is ready, with the customer waiting for fulfilment. Payment handling also differs. Pre-orders may use charge-later, deposit or payment-link models, while regular orders are always charged immediately at checkout.

Are pre-orders worth it for small businesses?
Yes. Pre-orders help smaller merchants validate demand and reduce inventory risk. Instead of guessing how much stock to order, you can use real pre-order numbers to plan your production run. The charge-later and deposit models also reduce the financial commitment required from customers, which can help smaller brands compete with larger ones.

How do I set up pre-orders on Shopify?
You’ll need a pre-order app to handle the checkout flow, payment collection and customer communication. Our complete guide on how to do pre-orders on Shopify walks through the full setup process.

Wrapping Up

Now you know how pre-orders work, from the step-by-step process to the four payment models and the data behind what makes them successful.

Pre-orders let you take orders before stock arrives, with flexible options for when and how to charge customers. Whether you use a charge-later model to reduce customer risk or a charge-upfront model to improve cash flow, the right approach depends on your product, your lead times and your customers.

The data from over 1 million pre-orders shows that customers are willing to wait, cancellation rates are low and discounts aren’t necessary to drive pre-order sales. Pre-orders work because customers want access to products they care about.

If you’re thinking about adding pre-orders to your store, start with our guide on how to pre-sell online or jump straight to setting up pre-orders on Shopify.

Pre-sell With PreProduct

7 day free trial with all plans

Contents

What Does Pre-Order Mean?
How Pre-Orders Work Step by Step
How Do You Pay for a Pre-Order?
Why Do Merchants Offer Pre-Orders?
When Do Pre-Orders Make Sense (and When They Don’t)
How Long Do Pre-Orders Take to Ship?
Pre-Order FAQs
Wrapping Up

Failed Shopify Payments: What They Mean and How to Fix Them

Few things are more frustrating than watching sales slip away because of a failed Shopify payments. Whether it’s a customer seeing “payment declined” at checkout or a deferred charge that won’t go through months after a pre-order was placed, payment failures cost merchants real revenue and can damage customer trust.

The good news? Most failed payments are fixable, and many are recoverable. Research shows that many failed charge payments can be recovered with proper retry logic and timing. But first, you need to understand what went wrong.

This guide breaks down the different types of Shopify payment failures, explains what each error code means, and walks through practical steps to diagnose, fix, and prevent them. We will also cover the unique challenges that pre-order merchants face with deferred payments and authorization expiration, topics most guides overlook entirely.

What causes Shopify payments to fail?

Payment failures fall into three main categories: customer-side issues, merchant-side issues, and platform/gateway problems. Understanding where the failure originated helps you fix it faster.

Customer-side issues are the most common. These include expired cards, insufficient funds, incorrect card details, and fraud detection blocks from the customer’s bank. Sometimes a customer’s bank simply flags the transaction as suspicious, especially for international purchases or unusually large orders.

Merchant-side issues typically involve configuration problems. Maybe your payment gateway credentials are incorrect, you’re still in test mode, or your fraud filters are too aggressive. These issues affect all customers, not just one.

Platform and gateway issues are less common but do happen. Shopify or your payment provider might experience outages, or there could be processing delays during high-traffic periods.

For merchants running pre-orders with charge-later payment models, there’s a fourth category: deferred payment failures. When you charge a customer weeks or months after their initial order, cards expire, accounts close, and customers forget they placed an order. This creates a unique set of challenges we’ll address in this guide.

Shopify payment error codes explained

When a payment fails, Shopify returns a standardized error code that tells you exactly what went wrong. Here’s a complete reference based on Shopify’s API documentation.

Card and bank declines

These errors indicate the customer’s bank or card issuer rejected the transaction:

Error Code	What It Means	What to Do
`CARD_DECLINED`	The card issuer declined the transaction without a specific reason	Customer should try a different card or contact their bank
`CALL_ISSUER`	The bank wants the customer to call them before approving	Customer must contact their card issuer directly
`PICK_UP_CARD`	The card has been reported lost or stolen	Customer needs to use a different payment method
`INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS`	Not enough money in the account	Customer should use a different card or add funds

The generic CARD_DECLINED is frustrating because the bank doesn’t always explain why. It could be fraud protection, spending limits, or account restrictions. The customer’s best option is to call the bank phone number on their card.

Card detail errors

These happen when the payment information entered doesn’t match what the bank has on file:

Error Code	What It Means	What to Do
`EXPIRED_CARD`	The card’s expiration date has passed	Customer needs to update their card details
`INCORRECT_NUMBER`	The card number is wrong	Customer should re-enter their card number carefully
`INCORRECT_CVC`	The security code (CVV/CVC) doesn’t match	Customer should check the 3-4 digit code on their card
`INVALID_CVC`	The security code format is incorrect	Customer should verify they’re entering digits only
`INVALID_EXPIRY_DATE`	The expiration date format is wrong	Customer should use MM/YY format

Card detail errors are usually simple to fix. The customer just needs to re-enter their information carefully.

Address verification failures

Address Verification Service (AVS) failures occur when billing address details don’t match the card issuer’s records:

Error Code	What It Means	What to Do
`INCORRECT_ZIP`	The ZIP or postal code doesn’t match	Customer should verify their billing ZIP code
`INCORRECT_ADDRESS`	The full billing address doesn’t match	Customer should check their complete billing address

AVS mismatches are common for customers who’ve recently moved or have multiple addresses on file with their bank.

Processing and configuration errors

These errors often indicate problems on the merchant side:

Error Code	What It Means	What to Do
`GENERIC_ERROR`	An unknown error occurred during processing	Retry the transaction; if persistent, contact support
`CONFIG_ERROR`	Your gateway or merchant configuration is wrong	Check your payment gateway settings and API credentials
`PROCESSING_ERROR`	Something went wrong during processing	Wait and retry; could be a temporary issue
`TEST_MODE_LIVE_CARD`	A real card was used but your gateway is in test mode	Switch your gateway from test to live mode

If you’re seeing CONFIG_ERROR or TEST_MODE_LIVE_CARD, the problem is almost certainly in your Shopify admin under Settings > Payments.

Regional and feature limitations

Some errors relate to what payment methods are available:

Error Code	What It Means	What to Do
`INVALID_COUNTRY`	The payment method isn’t available in the customer’s country	Offer alternative payment methods
`PAYMENT_METHOD_UNAVAILABLE`	The payment method is temporarily unavailable	Try a different payment method or wait
`UNSUPPORTED_FEATURE`	Your gateway doesn’t support a required feature	Check gateway capabilities or switch providers

Shopify payment status types

Beyond error codes, Shopify uses transaction statuses to indicate where a payment stands in its lifecycle:

SUCCESS: The transaction completed. Funds will settle to your account.
FAILURE: The transaction was rejected. No funds were captured.
PENDING: The transaction is still processing. This is normal for some payment methods.
ERROR: Something went wrong during processing, distinct from a decline.
AWAITING_RESPONSE: The system is waiting for a response from the payment gateway.
UNKNOWN: The status couldn’t be determined. Check your gateway dashboard.

What “Payment pending” means: When you see a pending status, it usually means Shopify is waiting for confirmation from the payment provider. For methods like bank transfers or some regional payment options, pending payments can take several days to clear. Most pending payments have an expiry date, typically around a week, after which they change to “Expired” if not completed.

For pre-order merchants, it’s important to distinguish between an authorization pending (waiting for you to capture a payment hold) and a deferred payment pending (waiting to charge a vaulted card). Authorization holds expire after 7 days on standard Shopify plans, which is why many pre-order apps use vaulted cards instead.

Authorization expiration: what pre-order merchants need to know

This section is critical if you’re taking pre-orders with lead times longer than a week. Understanding Shopify’s authorization periods can save you significant headaches.

Standard authorization period: Shopify Payments allows a 7-day authorization period. This means when a customer places an order, the payment is authorized (the funds are held on their card) but not captured. You have 7 days to capture that payment before the authorization expires.

What happens after 7 days: If you capture payment after the standard authorization period, Shopify charges an additional 1.75% fee on top of your normal processing fees. This adds up quickly on larger orders.

Extended authorization for Shopify Plus: Merchants on Shopify Plus may have access to extended authorization periods for certain card types, but this varies by issuing bank and isn’t guaranteed.

Why this matters for pre-orders: If you’re selling products that won’t ship for 30, 60, or 120+ days, the 7-day authorization model doesn’t work. By the time stock arrives, the authorization has long expired.

The solution: Charge-later with vaulted cards. Instead of authorizing and capturing later, charge-later pre-orders vault the customer’s card at checkout (securely storing the payment method) and charge it when you’re ready to ship. This bypasses the authorization period entirely.

According to our analysis of over one million pre-orders, 43.8% of pre-order listings use charge-later models, and 28.1% of pre-orders have lead times of 121-150 days. For these merchants, vaulted cards aren’t optional; they’re essential.

How to fix common Shopify payment failures

Now for the practical part. Here’s how to address the most common failure scenarios.

For checkout payment failures

When customers can’t complete checkout, work through this checklist:

Check your payment gateway setup: Go to Settings > Payments in your Shopify admin. Verify that your gateway is active, API credentials are correct, and you’re not in test mode.
Review your fraud filter settings: Overly aggressive fraud filters can block legitimate customers. Check your settings and consider loosening restrictions if you’re seeing high false-positive rates.
Verify Shopify’s status: Visit the Shopify status page to check for any ongoing incidents affecting payment processing.
Test with a real transaction: Run a small test purchase using a real card to confirm your setup is working correctly.
Offer multiple payment methods: If one method fails, customers can try another. Consider enabling Shop Pay, PayPal, Apple Pay, or Google Pay alongside credit cards.

If specific customers are experiencing issues, the error code will guide your response. For CARD_DECLINED or CALL_ISSUER, the customer needs to contact their bank. For INCORRECT_CVC or INVALID_EXPIRY_DATE, they just need to re-enter their details.

For failed deferred charges

When a charge-later pre-order or subscription payment fails, you need a recovery process:

Notify the customer immediately: Send an email explaining that their payment couldn’t be processed and provide a direct link to update their payment method.
Retry with smart timing: Don’t retry immediately after a failure. Wait 24 hours for the first retry. This gives temporary issues (like a bank’s fraud hold or a card limit reset) time to resolve.
Follow a dunning schedule: Industry best practice suggests retrying at 24 hours, then 3-5 days, then 7-10 days. After the final retry, send a last-chance notice before cancellation.
Make payment updates easy: Provide a customer portal where customers can update their payment method without contacting support. This self-service option dramatically improves recovery rates.
Send pre-charge notifications: For deferred charges, send an “upcoming charge” email 3-7 days before you plan to charge. This catches expired cards proactively and reminds customers the charge is coming.

If you’re using PreProduct for pre-orders, our failed charge recovery flow handles much of this automatically, including customer notifications and retry logic.

For failed payouts

When Shopify can’t send money to your bank account:

Verify bank account details: Double-check your account number and routing number in Settings > Payments > Shopify Payments.
Confirm currency settings: Ensure your bank account currency matches your Shopify Payments payout currency. Currency mismatches cause failed payouts.
Maintain a positive balance: If you’ve issued refunds or received chargebacks, you might have a negative balance. Shopify needs a positive balance to process payouts.
Check for account restrictions: Some banks have restrictions on business deposits or international transfers. Contact your bank if payouts consistently fail.

Recovering failed payments: dunning strategies that work

Failed payments don’t have to mean lost revenue. With the right recovery strategy, you can recapture the majority of failed transactions.

Why recovery matters: Failed payments can lead to involuntary churn rates of 20-40% monthly if left unaddressed. But research shows that many of these failures are recoverable with proper retry logic and customer communication.

Pre-dunning for deferred charges: The best failed payment is one that never happens. For pre-orders and subscriptions, send customers a notification 3-7 days before their scheduled charge. This email should:

Remind them a charge is coming
State the amount and what it’s for
Provide a link to update their payment method if needed

Immediate notification: When a payment fails, notify the customer within minutes. Your email should:

Clearly state that payment couldn’t be processed
Avoid accusatory language (their card wasn’t “rejected,” the payment “couldn’t be completed”)
Include a direct link to update payment information
Provide a deadline for resolution

Smart retry schedule:

24 hours after failure: First automatic retry. Resolves temporary holds and daily limit resets.
3-5 days after failure: Second retry with follow-up email. Catches customers who intended to update their card but forgot.
7-10 days after failure: Final retry with urgent notice. Make clear that the order will be cancelled without payment.

Customer self-service: The easier you make it to update payment information, the higher your recovery rate. A customer portal where customers can:

View their pending charges
Update their card on file
See their payment history

…will outperform email-only recovery every time.

Handling chargebacks and disputes

Chargebacks are different from payment failures, but they’re related. A chargeback happens when a customer disputes a charge with their bank after the payment was successful. The bank reverses the transaction and takes the money (plus a fee) from your account.

Common chargeback reasons:

Fraudulent transaction: The cardholder claims they didn’t authorize the purchase
Product not received: The customer says they never got their order
Product not as described: The customer claims the product was different than expected
Duplicate charge: The customer was charged twice
Unrecognized transaction: The customer doesn’t recognize the charge on their statement

The response process: When you receive a chargeback through Shopify Payments:

You’ll be notified with a deadline to respond (typically 7-21 days)
Gather evidence: Order confirmation, shipping tracking, delivery confirmation, customer communication, your terms and policies
Submit your response through the Shopify admin before the deadline
The card network reviews the evidence and makes a decision (can take up to 120 days)

Important: Always submit evidence, even if the customer says they’ve withdrawn the dispute. Without a formal withdrawal letter submitted as evidence, you could still lose.

Prevention strategies:

Use clear merchant descriptors so customers recognize charges
Send order confirmations and shipping notifications
Require signature on delivery for high-value orders
Maintain clear pre-order policies that customers agree to at checkout
Respond quickly to customer service inquiries

For pre-orders specifically, clear communication about lead times and expected ship dates prevents “product not received” disputes. When customers know what to expect, they’re less likely to dispute a charge out of confusion.

Preventing payment failures before they happen

The best approach to payment failures is preventing them in the first place.

At checkout:

Display pricing clearly, including taxes and shipping, before checkout
Offer multiple payment methods so customers have alternatives
Use address validation to catch typos before submission
Keep your fraud filters balanced; too strict means lost sales

Before deferred charges:

Send pre-charge notification emails 3-7 days in advance
Monitor for expiring cards and prompt updates proactively
Allow customers to update payment methods anytime via a portal
Set appropriate retry logic for failed charges

Ongoing monitoring:

Track your payment failure rate and abandonment metrics monthly
Test your checkout process regularly, especially after theme or app changes
Monitor the Shopify status page during high-traffic periods
Review failed transactions to identify patterns

For pre-orders specifically:

Set realistic lead time expectations on product pages
Send regular status updates during longer lead times
Use charge-later with vaulted cards for products shipping beyond 7 days
Implement dunning automation through Shopify Flow or your pre-order app

When you’re running pre-orders at scale, failed payment recovery should be automated, not manual. Tools like Shopify Flow can trigger customer notifications, schedule retries, and even cancel orders after a set number of failed attempts.

Conclusion

Failed Shopify payments are frustrating, but they’re manageable. Most failures can be diagnosed from the error code, fixed with the right troubleshooting steps, and recovered with smart dunning strategies.

Here’s the key takeaway: approach payment failures as a lifecycle, not a one-time fix.

Diagnose: Use error codes to understand what went wrong
Fix: Address the root cause, whether it’s configuration, customer card issues, or gateway problems
Recover: Implement retry logic and customer communication to recapture failed payments
Prevent: Put systems in place to reduce failures before they happen

For pre-order merchants, the standard authorization model doesn’t work for products with long lead times. If you’re shipping more than a week out, charge-later pre-orders with vaulted cards bypass authorization expiration entirely and give you the flexibility to charge when you’re ready to fulfill.

Payment failures will always happen. The difference between merchants who lose revenue and those who don’t comes down to having the right systems in place to catch and recover those failures before they become permanent losses.

Pre-sell With PreProduct

7 day free trial with all plans

Contents

What causes Shopify payments to fail?
Shopify payment error codes explained
Shopify payment status types
Authorization expiration: what pre-order merchants need to know
How to fix common Shopify payment failures
Recovering failed payments: dunning strategies that work
Handling chargebacks and disputes
Preventing payment failures before they happen
Conclusion

Pre-order Payment Models: Complete Guide to Charge Later, Deposits, Installments & More on Shopify

Prefer a video? Click here to see Oli walk through the various types.

In analyzing $85 million in pre-order sales across more than one million transactions, one pattern became clear: the pre-order payment model you choose can make or break your campaign. Yet most merchants struggle to understand when to use charge later versus deposits, or whether upfront payments make sense for their lead times.

The challenge is not a lack of options. Shopify merchants have access to five distinct pre-order payment models, each with different strengths, technical requirements and ideal use cases. The real problem is that guidance on choosing between them has been scattered across dozens of articles, leaving store owners to piece together a strategy through trial and error.

This guide consolidates everything you need to know about pre-order payment models on Shopify. Whether you are setting up pre-orders on Shopify for the first time or optimizing an existing strategy, you will learn when to use each approach based on real data from PreProduct’s analysis of 1M+ pre-orders, understand the technical requirements behind deferred charges, and walk away with a decision framework matched to your specific situation.

What Are Pre-order Payment Models?

A pre-order payment model defines when and how you collect money from customers who purchase products before they ship. This sounds straightforward, but selecting the right pre-order payment model ripples through every aspect of your business, from cash flow and refund rates to customer trust and operational complexity.

The five main approaches

Based on our data, Shopify merchants distribute across these types of pre-order payment models:

Charge later (deferred payment): 43.8% of pre-orders (75,781 listings)
Capture-only (payment links): 28.7% of pre-orders
Charge upfront: 14.9% of pre-orders
Deposit upfront with balance later: 12.6% of pre-orders
Multi-step installment plans: Emerging option for high-ticket items

The dominance of charge-later reflects a significant shift in merchant strategy. Until vaulted card technology became widely available through Shopify Payments in recent years, most merchants had no choice but to charge upfront or manually send payment links later.

Why your payment model choice matters

Your payment model affects nearly every metric that matters:

Conversion rates shift dramatically based on payment timing. Charge-later pre-orders remove the friction of paying for something you will not receive for weeks or months. Customers feel more comfortable committing when no money changes hands until the product ships.

Cash flow implications cut both ways. Charging upfront provides immediate revenue, but deposits and charge-later methods can actually improve cash flow predictability by reducing refund rates and cancellations.

Operational complexity increases with deferred charges. You need systems for failed payment recovery, customer communication about upcoming charges, and fulfillment holds to prevent premature shipping.

Technical foundation: vaulted cards

Understanding vaulted cards is essential for grasping why certain payment models work the way they do. When a customer completes checkout on a charge-later or deposit pre-order, their card details are securely stored (or “vaulted”) with Shopify Payments or PayPal. This allows you to charge the card later without the customer re-entering their payment information.

The critical difference between vaulted cards and traditional authorization holds: authorization holds expire. Shopify’s standard authorization period is just 7 days, with extended authorization available up to 30 days on Shopify Plus, but at a 1.75% surcharge.

Vaulted cards have no time limit. You can charge a customer 3 months after checkout at standard processing rates. This is why charge-later has become the dominant model for pre-orders with longer lead times.

Payment Model 1: Charge Upfront

Charge upfront is the simplest pre-order payment model. The customer pays in full at checkout, just like a regular order. The difference is that fulfillment is delayed until your product is ready to ship.

How it works

When a customer completes a charge-upfront pre-order, their payment processes immediately. Shopify creates an order in your admin with the payment captured. To prevent premature shipping, you need fulfillment holds configured so the order stays in a “hold” state until you release it.

When to use charge upfront

Charge upfront works best in specific scenarios:

Short lead times under 14 days: When customers will receive their order quickly, the friction of paying upfront is minimal. Restocks and short-timeline launches fall into this category.

Critical cash flow needs: If you need revenue immediately to fund production or cover costs, upfront payment guarantees that cash.

Established customer trust: Brands with loyal followings can ask for payment upfront without damaging conversion rates. Customers who know and trust you are less concerned about paying early.

Low refund risk products: Commodity items or products with predictable demand carry less risk of cancellation requests.

Pros and cons

Pros:

Immediate revenue recognition
Simplest operational model
Payment is verified and funds secured
Works with any payment gateway

Cons:

Higher refund request rates for longer lead times
Customer hesitation reduces conversion
More support inquiries about order status
Potential chargeback risk if delays occur

Our data shows 14.9% of merchants use charge upfront, typically for restocks and launches with confirmed, short timelines.

Payment Model 2: Charge Later (Deferred Payment)

Charge later has become the dominant pre-order payment model for good reason. This Shopify deferred payment pre-order approach allows customers to complete checkout without an immediate charge. Their card is vaulted securely, and you trigger the charge when ready to ship.

How it works

The checkout experience feels nearly identical to a regular purchase. The customer enters their payment details and completes the order. Behind the scenes, Shopify creates a payment mandate that vaults the card details. The order enters a “payment pending” state with a fulfillment hold.

When your inventory arrives or production completes, you trigger the charge. The vaulted card is billed, and the order transitions to paid status ready for fulfillment.

When to use charge later

Lead times over 30 days: This is the sweet spot. Authorization periods cannot cover this timeline, so vaulted cards are your only option for deferred payment without manual intervention.

Maximizing conversion: Customers convert at higher rates when they know payment happens only when the product ships. The psychological barrier of “paying for something I won’t get for months” disappears.

Testing market demand: If you are gauging interest in a new product, charge-later lets you collect real purchase commitments without asking customers to take financial risk.

Uncertain fulfillment timelines: When you cannot guarantee exact ship dates, charge-later gives you flexibility. Customers feel less anxious about delays when they have not paid yet.

Why charge later dominates

The numbers tell the story. 43.8% of pre-orders use charge-later on Shopify, representing 75,781 listings in our dataset. This is not random. Charge-later solves the fundamental tension of pre-orders: customers want products early, but they do not want to pay for products they cannot receive.

From a technical standpoint, vaulted cards eliminate the authorization period constraint entirely. Standard authorization holds expire at 7 days. Extended authorization costs an additional 1.75% and only extends to 30 days. Vaulted cards have no time limit at standard processing rates.

Technical requirements

Charge-later requires specific payment gateway support:

Shopify Payments: Full support for vaulted cards and deferred charges
PayPal: Supports vaulted cards for deferred payment
Other gateways: Generally do not support this model; use capture-only instead

You also need selling plan configuration with payment mandates and fulfillment holds to prevent orders from flowing to your 3PL before payment is collected.

Failed charge management

The main operational consideration with charge-later is handling failed charges. Cards expire, get cancelled, or hit spending limits. Our data shows 95%+ success rate for deferred charges when merchants follow good communication practices.

The keys to minimizing failed charges:

Send a “heads up” email 48-72 hours before charging
Provide an easy way to update payment details
Have dunning workflows for retry logic
Set clear policies for order cancellation after failed attempts

Payment Model 3: Deposit Upfront (Partial Payment)

The deposit pre-order payment model strikes a balance between charge-upfront and charge-later. You collect a portion of the payment immediately to validate commitment, then charge the balance when ready to ship.

How it works

At checkout, the customer pays a percentage of the total (typically 10-50%). Their card is vaulted for the remaining balance. When you are ready to fulfill, you trigger the balance charge through the vaulted card, then release for fulfillment.

When to use deposits

High-ticket items over $300: Larger purchases benefit from deposits because they validate genuine commitment. A customer willing to put down $200 on a $500 item is unlikely to cancel.

Custom or made-to-order products: When you incur costs to produce an item specifically for a customer, deposits protect you from cancellation losses.

Partial cash flow needs: If you need some revenue to fund production but want to keep conversion rates high, deposits provide a middle ground.

Long lead times with expensive goods: Combining high price points with extended timelines makes deposits particularly valuable.

Optimal deposit percentages

Based on merchant data and industry practices, here are recommended deposit percentages for Shopify pre-orders:

Price Range	Recommended Deposit
$50-$300	10-25%
$300-$1,000	25-40%
$1,000+	30-50%
Custom/made-to-order	40-50%
6+ month lead times	30-40%

The principle is straightforward: higher deposits for higher-risk scenarios. Made-to-order items that cannot be resold need stronger commitment signals. High-ticket items need deposits proportional to your exposure.

Pros and cons

Pros:

Validates customer commitment and reduces cancellations
Improves cash flow without charging full amount
Balances conversion rates with revenue needs
Protects against order abandonment

Cons:

More complex than single-payment models
Requires balance charge management
Customer support questions about two-part payment
Failed balance charges create partial-payment scenarios

Our data shows 12.6% of merchants choose deposits, with particular concentration in fashion, furniture, and custom goods. For a deeper dive into deposit and partial payment configurations, see our complete guide to Shopify partial payments.

Payment Model 4: Capture-Only (Payment Links)

The capture-only pre-order payment model represents the most flexible but least automated approach. Customers express interest and provide contact information at checkout, but no payment is collected or vaulted. When ready to charge, you send a manual payment link.

How it works

The customer completes a simplified checkout that captures their order details and contact information. No payment processes. When your product is ready, you generate and send a payment link. The customer clicks through to complete payment, and you fulfill the order.

When to use capture-only

Uncertain timelines: If you genuinely do not know when a product will ship, capture-only avoids the commitment of vaulting cards for an indefinite period.

Non-Shopify Payments stores: This is the only deferred payment option for stores using payment gateways other than Shopify Payments or PayPal.

Maximum flexibility: Some merchants prefer the explicit customer reconfirmation that comes with payment link conversion.

Demand testing at zero commitment: Capture-only lets you gauge interest with minimal friction, though conversion at payment time will be lower.

Pros and cons

Pros:

Works with any payment gateway
Maximum flexibility on timing
Customer explicitly reconfirms intent
No failed deferred charge risk

Cons:

Extra customer friction at payment time
Lower conversion rate at payment collection
Requires manual payment link sending
No payment guarantee from initial checkout

Our data shows 28.7% of merchants use capture-only. Many are stores without Shopify Payments, but others prefer the explicit reconfirmation step.

Payment Model 5: Multi-Step Installment Plans

The installment pre-order payment model splits the total into multiple scheduled payments, typically 2-4 charges spread across weeks or months. This approach is growing for high-ticket Shopify pre-order payment options where the full amount creates purchasing friction.

How it works

At checkout, the customer pays the first installment. Their card is vaulted for remaining payments. Subsequent charges trigger automatically on a defined schedule (weekly, monthly, or milestone-based). The customer receives visibility into their payment schedule through a portal.

When to use installments

Very high-ticket items over $1,000: When the total price creates genuine budget friction, spreading payments makes the purchase accessible.

Extended production timelines of 3+ months: Long timelines naturally align with spread payments, as customers pay over time while the product is being made.

Competing with Affirm/Klarna: Rather than sending customers to third-party financing, installment plans let you offer payment flexibility on your terms.

Premium product positioning: Installment options can signal premium status while making purchases accessible.

Setup and configuration

Shopify payment plans for pre-orders require:

Define the number of installments (2-4 is typical)
Set payment schedule (first payment at checkout, remaining on dates)
Configure customer portal for payment visibility
Optional: offer pay-early discount to encourage faster payment

Platform requirements

Native Shopify installment support requires Shopify Plus. However, apps like PreProduct enable multi-step payment plans for merchants on standard Shopify plans, opening this model to a broader range of stores.

Pros and cons

Pros:

Enables high-ticket sales that would otherwise not convert
Merchant-controlled terms (unlike third-party BNPL)
Spreads payment across production timeline
Customer portal creates positive touchpoints

Cons:

Higher operational complexity
More failed payment points to manage
Requires robust dunning workflows
Customer confusion possible with multiple charges

Comparing Pre-order Payment Models: Decision Framework

With five pre-order payment models to choose from, how do you decide? Start with your constraints, then optimize for your goals.

Quick reference comparison table

Model	Best For	Lead Time	Price Point	Cash Flow	Complexity
Charge Upfront	Short timelines	Under 14 days	Any	Immediate	Low
Charge Later	Long timelines	30-180 days	Any	Delayed	Medium
Deposits	High-ticket	Any	$300+	Partial	Medium
Capture-Only	Uncertain timing	Any	Any	Manual	Low
Installments	Very high-ticket	60+ days	$1,000+	Spread	High

Decision flowchart

Work through these questions in order:

1. What is your lead time?

If under 14 days, charge upfront works well. Customers expect quick delivery and do not mind paying immediately for something arriving soon.

If 14-30 days, charge-later or deposits both work. Authorization periods can technically cover this window, but vaulted cards are simpler and cheaper.

If over 30 days, charge-later is strongly preferred. Authorization periods cannot cover this timeline without expensive workarounds, and customer expectations favor paying at ship time.

2. What is your price point?

Under $300: Charge-later maximizes conversion. The amount is not high enough to warrant deposit complexity.

$300-$1,000: Deposits validate commitment on purchases large enough that cancellation creates real loss.

Over $1,000: Consider installments or substantial deposits. The full amount creates genuine budget friction for many customers.

3. What are your cash flow needs?

Need revenue immediately: Charge upfront or deposits provide cash at checkout.

Can wait for fulfillment: Charge-later offers better conversion without immediate revenue.

4. What is your payment gateway?

Shopify Payments or PayPal: All five models are available.

Other gateways: Capture-only is your deferred payment option.

Cost comparison

Understanding the fee implications helps inform your decision:

Standard processing: 2.9% + 30 cents (typical)
Extended authorization (after day 7): Additional 1.75%
Vaulted cards (charge-later/deposits): Standard rates only

This cost difference matters. On a $100 order held for 30 days, extended authorization would cost an extra $1.75 compared to using vaulted cards. At scale, this adds up quickly.

Best Practices for Any Pre-order Payment Model

Regardless of which pre-order payment model you choose, certain principles apply universally.

Clear customer communication

Transparency prevents support tickets and chargebacks:

Product page: Explain payment timing before the customer reaches checkout
Checkout: Reinforce terms with consent language
Confirmation email: Recap what the customer agreed to
Pre-charge notification: Send 48-72 hours before any deferred charge

Operational considerations

Set yourself up for smooth execution:

Test manually first: Run through the customer experience yourself before automating
Configure fulfillment holds: Prevent 3PLs from shipping before payment clears. Learn more about managing pre-order inventory in Shopify
Document refund policies: Know what happens when customers want to cancel
Train support team: Ensure they understand payment timing and can answer questions

Compliance requirements

Pre-orders carry regulatory considerations. According to Shopify’s pre-order guidance, merchants must be transparent about shipping timelines and refund policies. For detailed templates and guidance, see our Shopify pre-order policy guide.

FTC guidelines: In the US, you must ship within stated timeframes or offer cancellation
Clear policies: Display refund and cancellation terms prominently
Honest timelines: Under-promise and over-deliver on shipping estimates

Common Pre-order Payment Model Mistakes to Avoid

Learn from merchants who have struggled with pre-order payment model selection:

Payment model selection errors

Using charge upfront for 60+ day lead times: Customers grow anxious when they have paid but see no product. Refund requests spike, and support burden increases.

Missing authorization period deadlines: If you try to capture a held authorization after 7 days (or 30 on Plus), the charge fails. You then need to request payment again from the customer.

Deposits too low or too high: A 5% deposit does not validate commitment. A 75% deposit creates the same friction as charging upfront. Find the balance for your price point.

Technical pitfalls

Wrong payment gateway for deferred charges: Attempting charge-later without Shopify Payments or PayPal leads to failed implementations.

No fulfillment holds: Without holds, orders flow to your 3PL and ship before payment is collected on deferred models. See our guide on managing pre-orders with your 3PL for proper setup.

Missing failed payment recovery: Without dunning workflows, failed deferred charges become lost revenue.

Conclusion: Choosing Your Pre-order Payment Model

Choosing the right pre-order payment model comes down to matching your constraints (lead time, price point, payment gateway) with your goals (conversion, cash flow, operational simplicity).

Key takeaways

Charge-later dominates for good reason: 43.8% adoption reflects superior conversion for longer lead times
Deposits validate commitment: For $300+ items, partial payment upfront reduces cancellation risk
Match model to lead time: Under 14 days favors upfront; over 30 days requires vaulted cards
Vaulted cards eliminate authorization limits: Shopify Payments and PayPal enable unlimited deferred charge windows
Communication prevents problems: Clear expectations at every touchpoint reduce support burden

Next steps

Start by assessing your product catalog. Segment by lead time and price point. For each segment, identify the payment model that balances conversion with your operational needs.

If you have not yet chosen a pre-order solution, consider what payment flexibility you need. Not all apps support all five models.

For flexible pre-order payments with charge-later, deposits, and multi-step installments, explore PreProduct’s Shopify pre-order solution. With data from over one million pre-orders and support for all five payment models, you can implement the right approach for your business.

FAQ

Charge-later (deferred payment) is best for lead times over 30 days. Vaulted cards allow you to charge at standard processing rates without authorization period limits. Customers also prefer not paying until closer to shipment.

What is the best pre-order payment model for long lead times?

Yes. Most pre-order apps allow you to configure payment settings per listing. Use charge-upfront for restocks arriving in days, charge-later for new launches with longer timelines, and deposits for high-ticket custom items.

Can I use different payment models for different products?

For items $50-$300, use 10-25%. For $300-$1,000 items, use 25-40%. For items over $1,000 or custom/made-to-order products, 30-50% provides adequate commitment validation without creating excessive friction.

What deposit percentage should I charge?

Yes. Deposits create psychological commitment that reduces cancellation rates compared to charge-later. Customers who have put money down are more likely to complete the purchase. The effect is stronger with higher deposit percentages.

Do deposits reduce cancellations?

Native Shopify installment support requires Plus, but apps like PreProduct enable multi-step payment plans on standard Shopify plans.

Can I offer installments without Shopify Plus?

The card may have expired, been cancelled, or hit a limit. Best practice is sending pre-charge notification emails so customers can update payment details proactively. When charges fail, dunning workflows retry automatically and send update requests to customers.

What happens if a deferred charge fails?

Include payment timing on the product page, in checkout messaging, in confirmation emails, and through pre-charge notifications. Customers should never be surprised by a charge. Transparency builds trust and reduces chargebacks.

How do I communicate payment timing to customers?

Shopify Payments and PayPal support vaulted cards for deferred charges. Other gateways typically require capture-only (payment links) for deferred payment scenarios.